Judge View
Outcomes and Scoring
0 Points vs. Insufficient — What’s the Difference?
0 points — absolute zero. No partial credit, no evaluation of what was shown before the fault.
Insufficient — the exercise is capped at the Insufficient grade band (0–69% of max), but the judge still evaluates quality within that band. The dog showed something, worth some points — just not above the Insufficient ceiling.
Practical example on the horizontal ladder (10 p exercise):
- Jumps off in first half → 0 points — the rungs it did walk don’t count at all
- Jumps off after first half → Insufficient — judge evaluates what was shown, may award 3–6 points (max 6.5 = 69% of 10)
- Jumps off after the last rung → maximum Satisfactory — capped at 79%, so up to 7.5 points
Progression: 0 pts < Insufficient (up to 6.5/10) < max Satisfactory (up to 7.5/10) < full range
Logic: fault location reflects how much the dog actually demonstrated. First half = essentially nothing valid shown. Second half = dog completed most of the obstacle, deserves something but not a passing grade.
Warning / Termination / Disqualification
Warning (−5 pts per occurrence; 2nd warning = phase terminated)
- Non-adherence to TJ directive
- Prohibited help or touching D during nose work / UO/GW (except praise)
- Unsportsmanlike behaviour
- Relinquishing an exercise or part of an exercise
Termination (phase ends; points up to that moment kept, minus 61 pts in phase A / 31 pts in phase B)
- D leaves testing area, does not return after 3rd AC
- D shows no obedience after 3rd AC
- Lack of preparation / willingness to work / temperament flaws / physical limitations
- After 2nd warning
- Giving food or motivational items during work
- After a 2nd false alert
Disqualification (entire test = 0; notation in scorebook; written report to IRO)
- Unsportsmanlike behaviour before, during, or after test
- Use of forceful training aids anywhere in the testing area
- Aggressive behaviour of D against people or animals
- Injury to a VP
- Pulling out from the test without reason
Scoring Reminders
- Table rounds to 0.5 points.
- Qualification thresholds: Excellent ≥96%, Very Good ≥90%, Good ≥80%, Satisfactory ≥70%, Insufficient <70%.
- A marginal repeated fault (e.g., consistently slightly crooked GS) should not be hammered in every exercise — incorporate into the overall picture discussion instead.
- Splayed DH stance: universally faulty, devalues that exercise.
Source: judge/05_outcomes_and_scoring.md